Understanding the most common reasons wills are challenged can help you take proactive steps to reduce the likelihood of a dispute and ensure your wishes are carried out as intended.
Common Grounds for Challenges
Wills may be challenged for a variety of legal and practical reasons, some of which include:
Capacity Concerns
One of the most common grounds for challenging a will is questioning whether the person had the mental capacity to make it at the time it was signed. In legal terms, “capacity” means that the person understood the nature and effect of their will, the extent of their assets, and who might reasonably expect to benefit from their estate.
Capacity concerns often arise when a will is made during a period of illness, cognitive decline, or later in life. Without proper documentation regarding capacity or professional involvement, these situations can leave room for doubt.
Undue Influence
A will may also be challenged if there are any concerns that someone else pressured, coerced, or influenced the person into making certain decisions in their will. This can happen in situations where a person is vulnerable or dependent on another individual for care or support. Undue influence can be subtle, making it difficult to detect but still significant enough to raise legal concerns.
Unclear or Outdated Documents
Ambiguities, inconsistencies, or outdated provisions in a will can create confusion and open the door to disputes or challenges. For example, if a will references assets that no longer exist, or doesn’t account for major life changes such as a marriage, divorce, or the birth of children or grandchildren, beneficiaries may disagree on how the will should be interpreted.
Perceived Unfairness
In BC, wills can be challenged on the grounds that they do not make adequate provisions for certain family members, particularly spouses and children. This type of claim is often brought under the province’s wills variation legislation, allowing the court to adjust a will if it is found to be unfair or not reflective of the will-maker’s legal and moral obligations.
Reducing the Risk
While it is nearly impossible to eliminate all risk, thoughtful and clear estate planning can significantly reduce the likelihood of your will being challenged.
Some key steps include:
- Keeping your will up to date
Review and potentially update your will regularly, especially after major life events such as marriage, separation, the birth of children, or significant changes in your financial situation. - Clearly documenting your intentions
Provide clear explanations for your decisions, particularly if they may be unexpected, to help reduce misunderstandings and disputes. - Seeking professional legal advice
Working with an experienced estate planning lawyer helps ensure your will is properly drafted, legally valid, and reflective of current laws in BC. - Addressing capacity proactively
If there could be any question about your capacity, additional steps such as medical assessments or detailed lawyer notes, can help support the validity of your will. - Communicating your wishes where appropriate
While it is not always necessary, discussing your plans in advance with family members can sometimes prevent any surprises and reduce the likelihood of conflict.
Conclusion
Although not all challenges can be avoided, proactive estate planning can go a long way in protecting your estate and minimizing the risk of disputes. A clear, well-drafted, and current will provides guidance, reduces uncertainty, and helps ensure your wishes are respected.
Find out more about our estate planning services and book a consultation here.
Stay up to date with the latest legal scoop by signing up for our newsletter.
Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or legal advice. Consult with qualified professionals to create a personalized estate plan suitable for your specific circumstances.
