Appointing a guardian in your will is the most effective way to protect your children’s future. But what happens if no guardian is named, or if the chosen guardian is contested? Understanding how guardianship is handled in probate can help you make informed decisions and avoid unnecessary legal disputes.
What is Guardianship?
Guardianship is the legal authority to make decisions on behalf of a minor child. This includes decisions about:
- Custody and Living Arrangements: Where the child will live and who will be responsible for their daily care.
- Education and Healthcare: Choices about schooling, medical care, and overall welfare.
- Financial Management: Managing the child’s inheritance or assets until they reach the age of majority.
In addition to the guardian, who is responsible for the child’s physical and emotional well-being, you may wish to appoint a trustee who can manage money left to the child in trust and has a fiduciary duty to use the funds for their best interest. In some cases, one person may serve as both, or separate people may be appointed for each role.
Why Appoint a Guardian in Your Will?
Naming a guardian in your will ensures that your children are cared for by someone you trust. Without this appointment, the court will decide who becomes the guardian, which could result in disputes, delays and other unintended outcomes such as:
- Family Disputes: Relatives may disagree about who is best suited to raise the children.
- Court Delays: The probate court must investigate and evaluate potential guardians, leading to delays and uncertainty for the children.
- Unintended Guardianship: If no suitable family member is identified, the children could be placed in foster care.
How to Appoint a Guardian in Your Will
1. Choose the Right Person
Selecting a guardian is a very personal decision, but the following factors are important to consider:
- Values and Parenting Style: Choose someone who shares your values, beliefs, and approach to parenting.
- Emotional Bond: Ensure the guardian has a positive and nurturing relationship with your children.
- Age and Health: Consider the potential guardian’s age, health, and ability to care for the children until they reach adulthood.
- Financial Stability: While the guardian does not have to be wealthy, they should have the means to provide a stable environment.
- Willingness and Availability: Confirm that the person is willing and able to take on the responsibility. Always have an open and honest conversation with your chosen guardian before naming them in your will.
2. Name an Alternate Guardian
Circumstances can change unexpectedly. Naming an alternate or backup guardian ensures continuity of care if your first choice is no longer able or willing to be the guardian.
3. Specify Instructions and Wishes
Clearly outline your wishes for your children’s upbringing. While these instructions are not legally binding, they serve as valuable guidance for the guardian. Outline specifics such as:
- Education Preferences: Schools, extracurricular activities, and educational philosophy.
- Religious or Cultural Practices: Important traditions, religious education, or cultural values.
- Living Arrangements: Whether you want the children to remain in a specific community or school district.
What Happens in Probate Court?
If both parents pass away and a guardian is named in the will, the probate court will:
- Review the Will: Verify the validity of the will and the named guardian.
- Evaluate the Guardian: Ensure the guardian is suitable, considering their relationship with the child, financial stability, and overall ability to provide care.
- Grant Legal Authority: Issue guardianship papers, giving the named guardian legal authority over the child’s welfare and/or finances.
If no guardian is named or the chosen guardian is contested, the court will:
- Consider Family Members and Interested Parties: Close relatives or individuals with a significant relationship to the child may petition the court for guardianship.
- Conduct a Background Check: Investigate potential guardians to ensure the child’s safety and well-being.
- Prioritize the Child’s Best Interests: The court’s primary concern is the child’s best interests, which may override the parents’ wishes if circumstances have changed (for example if the named guardian is no longer suitable).
Challenges and Potential Disputes
Several issues can complicate the guardianship process in probate. These include:
- Contested Guardianship: Disputes among family members can delay the process and create emotional stress for the children. Mediation may help resolve conflicts, but in contentious cases, the court will make the final decision.
- Unfit Guardian Concerns: If concerns about the chosen guardian’s suitability arise (e.g., health issues, financial instability, or a criminal history), the court may appoint an alternate guardian.
- Blended Families and Step-Parents: In complex family structures, the court carefully considers the child’s relationship with each potential guardian.
Financial Considerations
Raising a child involves significant financial responsibilities. To ensure the guardian has the necessary resources:
- Set Up a Trust: Establishing a testamentary trust allows you to control how and when funds are distributed to your children. The trustee manages the assets, ensuring they are used for the child’s benefit.
- Life Insurance and Financial Planning: Designate life insurance beneficiaries and plan for sufficient financial support to cover education, healthcare, and living expenses.
When to Update Your Guardianship Plan
Life circumstances change, and so do your children’s needs. Review and update your guardianship provisions when:
- Your chosen guardian’s circumstances change (health, relocation, or change in relationship).
- Your children’s needs evolve (special educational requirements or health concerns).
- Your family dynamics change (remarriage, new children, or blended families).
Conclusion
Appointing a guardian for minor children is one of the most important decisions parents can make in their estate plan. By carefully selecting a guardian, providing detailed instructions, and ensuring financial security, you can protect your children’s future and minimize uncertainty during a difficult time. Consulting with an experienced estate planning lawyer can help you make informed choices and create a legally sound guardianship plan that reflects your wishes and safeguards your children’s best interests.
Find out more about our estate planning services and book a consultation here.
Stay up to date with the latest legal scoop by signing up for our newsletter.
Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or legal advice. Consult with qualified professionals to create a personalized estate plan suitable for your specific circumstances.
